The
forklift battery vs. other power type’s debate is still
going on. Is “filling up” better than
“charging up?” It goes without saying that both types would undoubtedly be able
to perform the same basic functions, but differences do arise in regards to
optimal environmental and task conditions.
So
how do you therefore decide on whether to go for the forklift battery
option or the good old internal combustion engine option? Well below are the
key points the ongoing debate seems to centre around:
Several
distinct pros and cons can be drawn up for these two options. Once having gone
through these one will be better suited and equipped to make the best decision.
The
primary advantage that many people see is that the purchase price is lower,
which makes this a very attractive option if you are just starting out. With
regards to power output, IC provides increased acceleration and torque which is
clearly visible when the forklift encounters steep gradients and slopes in the
work place. In line with this the IC type is better suited to more challenging
and rougher environmental conditions. No charging area is required and the
vehicles can more easily cope with extended work cycles with only a quick
refuel required.
Unfortunately
there are a couple of disadvantages. Firstly IC engines require continued
maintenance and care. This is usually in the form of periodic overhauls and
adds extra cost, not to mention the cost of down time. As we know IC provides
more power, but with this is often accompanied by vibrations coursing through
the vehicle which can take some getting used to. The sound created by the
engine can be a draw back especially if the lift is operated in confined areas
– it can be quite unpleasant for surrounding work groups and the operator
himself. A final health concern is the emissions that accompany combustion such
as carbon monoxide and lead – which are more harmful in confined unaired
spaces. Then there are the basic disadvantages – such as the cost of fuel and
general increased bulkiness of the lift (which does impact on the turning
radius and maneuverability.)
The
first thing that people click on to is that less time and money is spent on
engineering and servicing as the need for overhauls is reduced. Form this one
can understand why the life span of these lifts is longer than its IC cousin. A
major advantage (especially when it comes to other work groups and their
productivity) is the near to none noise pollution as well as there being no
emissions of harmful gasses such as carbon monoxide. The compactness of the
electric motor means increased maneuverability and a greater turning circle.
Another great benefit is the ability for the lifts to be programmed with
different speeds which can be set to coincide with certain tasks. Then there is
the obvious fact that it is very cheap to recharge the batteries.
However
the bad has to come with the good. Initial purchase of an electric motor lift
is considerably more costly than an IC one, and with weaker acceleration and
torque electric lifts are not well suited to rough work conditions. Work cycles
are usually shorter as power cells only last for a set period of time, and
these deplete faster if the vehicle has to climb steep ramps and slopes. An
area also has to be set aside for charging – and if you have a large fleet this
can cause and space inconvenience.
This
page has outlined the basic differences only, and it is advised that if you
require any more information you contact Repolift.